Aiper Scuba S1 vs Dolphin Liberty 200
Get the Dolphin Liberty 200. The Aiper saves you $319, but cleans less well and won't last as long.
VS
| Feature | Scuba S1 | Liberty 200 |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning | Good | Better |
| Filter | Small | Larger |
| Sun ledges | No | Yes |
| Service | Online only | Dealer network |
| Typical price | $580 | $899 |
Get the Scuba S1 if…
- Budget is the main thing.
- Your pool stays fairly clean.
Get the Liberty 200 if…
- You want better cleaning and a longer life.
- You have a tanning ledge.
Why the Liberty 200 wins
The Liberty 200 has the better filter, cleans sun ledges and has Dolphin's service network behind it. The Aiper is fine for a smaller pool on a tight budget.
How we reached this verdict
We compared independent expert reviews with the manufacturer's specifications and the problems owners keep reporting, then checked it's sold at a major retailer where you live. We don't test products ourselves.
Sources: The Pool Nerd, Bob Vila, manufacturer specifications.
Updated 6 Oct 2026How we decide
Our verdict is an opinion based on published reviews and owner reports, not our own testing. Specs, prices and availability change — check the manufacturer's and retailer's details before you buy. Terms & disclaimer